Moderate the listing, not just the photo
A lampshade listed as a floor lamp shows why a moderator needs the seller’s terms, category, photo, and marketplace rule in the same review.
Published by Youzu · Editorial policy
- Published
- Updated
- Reading time
- 2 min read
What changed: Revised article and supporting media
In this article
Moderate the item the seller is offering, not the image in isolation. An ordinary photo of a floor lamp could be appropriate for one listing and misleading in another. A reviewer needs to know what the buyer would receive and which marketplace rule applies before deciding what to change.

Is the lamp base included?
Consider a fictional listing titled “Linen lampshade only.” Its description says the base is sold separately. The seller chose Floor lamps, and the first photo shows a fully assembled lamp. Suppose this marketplace requires the first image to show the item for sale on its own; it allows styled photos later in the gallery.
There’s nothing inherently objectionable in the photo. The problem is that the category and lead image suggest a full lamp while the seller offers only the shade. Moving the listing to Lampshades would fix the category but leave the buyer looking at the wrong lead image. Changing the title to “Floor lamp” to match the photo would promise a base the seller explicitly excluded.
What the reviewer and seller each need
Keep the finding on the listing. Give the reviewer the seller’s wording, selected category, photo position, applicable rule, severity, and current status. A useful seller note for this example would be: “Your description says the base is sold separately. Choose Lampshades and make a shade-only photo the first image. You can keep the assembled lamp later in the gallery.” That gives the seller a fix without treating the item itself as prohibited.
Youzu’s review queue example organizes flagged listings by status, severity, and rule. A flag means there’s a finding to resolve; it isn’t a final rejection. The classifieds moderation guide explains how to give a decision a stable reason code. Keep the reason distinct from the outcome so an appeal can show what the reviewer changed and why.
Try the correction both ways
Give a reviewer the original listing and a corrected copy with the right category and a shade-only lead photo. Leave the styled photo second. Under the example rule, the original needs attention; the corrected listing should not be held merely for keeping that second photo. If both trigger the same finding, check which images the rule examines. If neither triggers it, check whether the reviewer ever sees the offer terms. That small test distinguishes a catalog mistake, a policy problem, and a seller who has already done what you asked.